# Claim review — roadmap-review-v1

Scope: every factual or outcome claim in script.en.md, and every claim from the canonical source script that was removed.
The canonical script is used as an educational reference only, not as authority for current numbers.

## A. Claims kept in the review draft

| # | Claim in draft | Type | Support | Decision |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| K1 | "Where should I start?" is a common beginner question in trading communities | General observation, no number | Reflected in the canonical script's audience research; no count is stated in the draft | KEEP — unquantified |
| K2 | Advanced concepts build on chart language and structure | Educational opinion | Framed as the channel's teaching view, not a measured fact | KEEP — opinion wording |
| K3 | Charts explained in hindsight make moves look obvious | Educational opinion | General hindsight-bias point; no study cited | KEEP — no statistic attached |
| K4 | A fixed small risk per trade is a common rule in many trading education courses | General statement | Widely taught risk rule; no specific percentage is recommended | KEEP — no number, no promise |
| K5 | Demo/historical practice does not predict live results; spreads, slippage and emotions differ | Risk disclosure | Standard risk disclosure | KEEP |
| K6 | Many traders lose money | Risk disclosure | Kept as unquantified disclosure; no percentage stated | KEEP — unquantified |
| K7 | Target length about 8 minutes | Production estimate | Word-count estimate only; no recorded audio | KEEP — labelled estimate |

## B. Claims removed from the canonical source (not used)

| # | Removed item | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| R1 | Historic pain-comment counts (education-gap totals) | Historic dataset counts; not re-verified for this draft |
| R2 | Specific community post, its date and its engagement points | Single dated external post; not re-verified, and on-screen use would need rights review |
| R3 | Quoted answers attributed to commenters ("just learn ...", "watch my livestream") | Not traceable to a verified source in this package |
| R4 | Viewer quote cards with like counts | Third-party comments with unverified engagement numbers; consent/rights not reviewed |
| R5 | Fixed practice-trade count presented as a requirement | Arbitrary number presented as a rule; replaced by "the number is your choice" |
| R6 | First-person research narrative ("I pulled ... comments") | First-person claim not reproducible in this draft |
| R7 | Free-course, community link, signal block and sales CTA | Not part of this review scope; CTA limited to subscribe + self-review |
| R8 | Posting-hour statistics | Historic analytics; not needed for script review |
| R9 | Any implied outcome ("stop losing", "fix your results") | Outcome/causal promise not supportable |

## C. Open questions for Alan

1. Is "about 8 minutes" the right target, or should the draft be shortened?
2. Should Section 3 use a text card only (current plan) or a new original diagram?
3. Confirm the subscribe-only CTA for this review draft.